Well, a pseudo-snow day. Today was already a school holiday, but last night we had our second snowfall of the season and woke to everything sparkly and white. We only got about an inch and it was already starting to drip, but so pretty! I always think the best snowfalls are the ones that don't leave you with icy roads and heaps of snow to shovel, so this was pretty fab. I'm hunkered down with hot chocolate and my daughter and memoirs of women who worked as lady's maids.
Yesterday I managed to get through ALL of the second season of "Downton Abbey" just in time to see the last episode, and I curled up with my companion book. One of the things that irritates me vastly about some of the criticisms of "Downton" is when people whip out the "that would never happen" sniffiness. Until and unless you read MASSES of firsthand accounts--memoirs, journals, letters, autobiographies, etc.--you would think that people did things a very specific way and never deviated. And that would be very, very wrong. At no time in history have people behaved in one precise fashion with no room for individuality. Even in totalitarian regimes, people are still people--complex and messy and interesting. (That's why a Nazi guard who shows a glimmer of humanity, a queen who abdicates, a priest who breaks his vows are all more intriguing than people in the same roles who do precisely what is expected of them.) And it is straight up ABSURDLY simplistic to say, "Victorians wouldn't do that" or "Regency ladies never did this". It's as ridiculous as saying that "all Americans in the 21st century believed THIS way." It just doesn't fly.
In just five minutes of reading one of the lady's maid memoirs, I learned about a second parlourmaid who valeted for the master of the house, an earl marrying the daughter of a local registry office clerk, and a head parlourmaid taking on the duties of the butler. All of those things would fall under the heading of "would never happen", but they DID. Were they out of the ordinary? Yes, that's what makes them worth remarking upon and worth including in a fictional work as well. Unremarkable people doing unremarkable things makes for bad storytelling. That's why we only write about people who are either very interesting or doing very interesting things or perhaps both. To criticize any storytelling--whether the medium is film or novel--on the grounds that "that wouldn't have happened" is narrow-minded and silly if you haven't done the research to back up your opinion. (And I'm talking almost exclusively about social conventions and domestic arrangements here as opposed to historical fact.) Some of the most outrageous things in the Julia Grey series are not wholly drawn from imagination but were based on real people doing very odd things. And this is a very long way round of saying that while I can certainly appreciate "Downton" criticism that is based on preferences, it makes my back teeth itch to hear it savaged by people who know almost nothing about history who nitpick it on the grounds that it isn't historical...Really? Go watch "The Tudors" and THEN complain about historical inaccuracy. I'll wait. In a television landscape littered with trash like "Jersey Shore" and any talk show that uses paternity testing as an audience hook, "Downton" is a thoughtful, intelligent, elegant, thinking person's soap opera and I say bring on season three.
Anyway, rant over. The trip to Phoenix was a very nice break indeed--and one of the spontaneous and thoroughly enjoyable highlights was spending the day at the Arabian horse show. Most people would be surprised to find that the smell of livestock barns is pure comfort and nostalgia to me, and I am never happier than when my boots are dusty and I'm within arm's reach of large animals--and I say this as a person who does not ride. Horses, cattle, pigs, I love them all, and the smell of hay and warm livestock is bliss. (If someone would put that in a candle, I'd buy an armful...) The event at the Poisoned Pen was great fun, and huge thanks to all who came! Champagne and chocolates were in good supply, and it is always such fun to do an event with Lauren Willig. I get to see her next month at the Virginia Festival of the Book, so I am well-pleased indeed!
The trip home, however, was less than delightful. It took fourteen hours thanks to a mechanical delay and rebooking in Charlotte, but I was so happy to be off the plane from Phoenix that I would have happily walked home from there thanks to the girl behind me WHO NEVER SHUT UP. I'm not kidding. It was a three and a half hour narcissistic drone in a VERY loud voice. It was so disruptive that the flight attendant snickered as he walked past and said, "Headphones, $3." For the first hour, we were all pretty low-key about hating her. You know how it is--you are made miserable by something in public but you don't initially make a big deal out of it in case you're the only one. But by the second hour, my row had actually formulated a plan to eat her first if we ended up wrecked on a beach somewhere.
I tried drowning her out with my ipod, but I could clearly hear her above Aerosmith, and here's what I heard: she's a trophy wife whose husband is twenty-two years her senior, they have no formal dining room because they preferred a game room complete with pool table and Ms. Pac-Man, they have a "playful" marriage, her wedding dress cost $7000, her wedding cake was chocolate with chocolate icing and pink quilting but NO FONDANT because she doesn't like it, she needs an expert architect to replace glass sliding doors in her house, her father's toe was amputated due to "pre-diabetes", her husband Rob is never home because he travels a lot due to work, he's recently taken up skydiving but he's had a couple of parachute malfunctions, she has a Kindle, she has a 5000 square foot home, she grew up in California and for her bridal shower her mother flew in her childhood best friend, an aesthetician who did facials for the entire bridal party for free, she's got a brother named Jeff. AND THAT WAS JUST A HALF HOUR'S CONVERSATION. Did I mention she brought out wedding pictures at one point?
Now, when we compared notes with the guys in the row behind us, they were inclined to feel sorry for the man she was talking to until I pointed out that it was his fault for MAKING EYE CONTACT with her. They agreed, and it was unanimously decided that he would be eaten second. I have flown rather a lot, and this was absolutely the first time I have ever seen a group of strangers so completely united in their desire to debone another human being. When she got up to use the lavatory opposite me, my husband--who was sporting MacGyvered earplugs from a cocktail napkin--begged me to block her in, using my own body if I had to. It was epically, awesomely awful to be in this girl's vicinity, and the best part is how COMPLETELY clueless she was. I have never met anyone so lacking in self-awareness, and I have to admit, I understand the trophy wife dynamic even less now because sure, you can bring a shapely blonde home for your "playful" marriage, but at some point YOU HAVE TO TALK TO HER. I suppose that's why Rob travels so much...and that would explain the parachute incidents. I personally think they must be cries for help. In addition to being stratospherically self-involved, she was crass, indiscreet, and common as pig tracks, as we say in the south. (Ladies do not drop f-bombs in conversations with men they have just met loudly and in public. EVER. And if anybody on "Downton Abbey" does, I will be the first one to complain because it just is NOT DONE.)
Actually, the most entertaining part for me was the last quarter hour of the flight when my husband was listing all the things he didn't want me to do to her when the plane landed. They included dirty looks, direct confrontation, voodoo dolls, and any form of eye contact whatsoever. He knows me too well...